Best Fishing Spots Near Middletown, New York, United States
Find the best fishing spots in and around Middletown, New York, United States!
This city is home to a variety of fishing locations, making it ideal for both
locals and visitors. Explore serene lakes, well-stocked ponds, and nearby rivers,
and discover the different fish species available. Whether you're planning a quick
fishing trip or a full day of angling, our selection and hotspot map will help you
find the best fishing spots in Middletown, New York, United States.
Top Fishing Spots (419)
- Lockenhurst PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Indigot CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- Art Fords LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Willow LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Deer LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Glen LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake FlorenceMiddletown, New York, US
- Holp PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Schillings LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Mud PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Cliff LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Lebanon Lake BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- McAuleys LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Mongaup Falls ReservoirMiddletown, New York, US
- Zieglers PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Sprague BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Mill BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Echo LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Black Walnut Island ChannelMiddletown, New York, US
- Toasperns PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Stewart BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Black LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Cahoonzie LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Delfongos PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Edgewood LakesMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake ArkinMiddletown, New York, US
- Berry BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Cape PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Swinging Bridge ReservoirMiddletown, New York, US
- Cranberry PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Chestnut Ridge PondMiddletown, New York, US
- The GulfMiddletown, New York, US
- Halfmoon LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Hankins PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Heintein PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Hawthorne LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Holly Street DitchMiddletown, New York, US
- Hollow BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Holleys PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Homowack KillMiddletown, New York, US
- Hull PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Honk LakeMiddletown, New York, US
Hunter BrookMiddletown, New York, US- Horseshoe BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Horse BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Joe CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake HuntingtonMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake JerryMiddletown, New York, US
- Irish DitchMiddletown, New York, US
- Indian Field PondMiddletown, New York, US
Next
Showing page 1 of 9
Fishbox
FISHING LICENSE
Click to find out where to buy a fishing license, types of fishing licenses available, etc.
Find Your Next Fishing Spots Near Middletown, New York, United States
Top 30 spots
- Indigot Creek
- Art Fords Lake
- Willow Lake
- Deer Lake
- Glen Lake
- Lake Florence
- Holp Pond
- Schillings Lake
- Mud Pond
- Cliff Lake
- Lebanon Lake Brook
- McAuleys Lake
- Mongaup Falls Reservoir
- Zieglers Pond
- Sprague Brook
- Mill Brook
- Echo Lake
- Black Walnut Island Channel
- Toasperns Pond
- Stewart Brook
- Black Lake
- Cahoonzie Lake
- Delfongos Pond
- Edgewood Lakes
- Lake Arkin
- Horseshoe Lake
- Berry Brook
- Cape Pond
- Beaver Pond
- Lockenhurst Pond
Let’s stay in touch!
Join our newsletter for the best fishing trips