Best Fishing Spots Near Middletown, New York, United States
Find the best fishing spots in and around Middletown, New York, United States!
This city is home to a variety of fishing locations, making it ideal for both
locals and visitors. Explore serene lakes, well-stocked ponds, and nearby rivers,
and discover the different fish species available. Whether you're planning a quick
fishing trip or a full day of angling, our selection and hotspot map will help you
find the best fishing spots in Middletown, New York, United States.
Top Fishing Spots (419)
- North Branch Basket CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- Trout PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Creamery BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Narrow Falls BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- South Branch Pakanasink CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- Theodore Gordon BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Hemp Meadow BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Judson BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- North Branch Callicoon CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- West Branch Beer KillMiddletown, New York, US
- Nevele LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Mercer BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Bush KillMiddletown, New York, US
- Toronto LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Black Lake CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- West Branch Mongaup RiverMiddletown, New York, US
- Feagles LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Shingle KillMiddletown, New York, US
- Monhagen BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Binnewater PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Gabriel LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Pine KillMiddletown, New York, US
- Willsey BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Pakanasink CreekMiddletown, New York, US
- Eurich DitchMiddletown, New York, US
- Jones BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake JeffersonMiddletown, New York, US
- Grassy Swamp PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Tusten Mountain LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Hazel BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Carlson PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Bascom BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Shandelee BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Spring BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake OpheliaMiddletown, New York, US
- Wheelers PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Schumacher PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Deep Hollow BrookMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake FlorenceMiddletown, New York, US
- Big PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Alta LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Amber LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Anawanda LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Baileys LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake La BarrMiddletown, New York, US
- Beaverdam PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Chestnut Ridge PondMiddletown, New York, US
- Clear LakeMiddletown, New York, US
- Lake DeVenogeMiddletown, New York, US
- Deer LakeMiddletown, New York, US
Next
Showing page 1 of 9
Fishbox
FISHING LICENSE
Click to find out where to buy a fishing license, types of fishing licenses available, etc.
Find Your Next Fishing Spots Near Middletown, New York, United States
Top 30 spots
- Trout Pond
- Creamery Brook
- Narrow Falls Brook
- South Branch Pakanasink Creek
- Theodore Gordon Brook
- Hemp Meadow Brook
- Judson Brook
- North Branch Callicoon Creek
- West Branch Beer Kill
- Nevele Lake
- Mercer Brook
- Bush Kill
- Toronto Lake
- Black Lake Creek
- West Branch Mongaup River
- Feagles Lake
- Shingle Kill
- Monhagen Brook
- Binnewater Pond
- Gabriel Lake
- Pine Kill
- Willsey Brook
- Pakanasink Creek
- Eurich Ditch
- Jones Brook
- Lake Jefferson
- Grassy Swamp Pond
- Tusten Mountain Lake
- Hazel Brook
- North Branch Basket Creek
Let’s stay in touch!
Join our newsletter for the best fishing trips